Insights / AI search visibility

Not showing up in AI answers? It's one of five problems.

Teams default to "we need more content" when the real problem is somewhere else. Here are the five I see, with a quick test for each.

This one comes up in nearly every CMO conversation I have: "We're not showing up in ChatGPT. What do we fix?"

The hard part is diagnosis. Teams default to "we need more content" when the real problem is somewhere else. Here are the five I see, with proof from practitioners publishing real results and a quick test for each.

Technical: AI can't read the page

Vercel and MERJ found that none of the major AI crawlers (ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity) run JavaScript. If your copy loads through JavaScript, those bots see an empty page.

Quick test: Run a key page through Lily Ray's free LLM Content Visibility Scanner to see what AI bots see.

Copy: the answer is buried

Kevin Indig's research shows ChatGPT pulls most citations from the top 10 to 20% of a page. Seer Interactive restructured 11 existing articles to answer the question up front and grew AI Overview citations 344% in five months.

Quick test: Does each priority page answer the buyer's question in the first two paragraphs?

Positioning: you aren't the obvious answer

Josh Blyskal at Profound found AI passes over "schedule a demo" pages in favor of pages that actually answer the question. Fire&Spark built one piece around a client's own clinical trial data: 275 AI citations in 30 days, first on 14 of 20 tracked prompts.

Quick test: Name the three questions you want to own. Do you have first-party proof for each?

Off-page: others aren't talking about you

Across 75,000 brands, Ahrefs found brand mentions on other sites track AI Overview visibility far more closely than backlinks do. When Foundation asked ChatGPT about 15 SEO Week sponsors, 58% of the sources it cited were content those brands didn't own.

Quick test: Ask ChatGPT about your company and list every source it cites that you didn't write.

Consistency: your facts don't match

When sources disagree or stay vague, AI goes with whatever is most specific, right or wrong. MIT Sloan Management Review described a company that ChatGPT said had five funds instead of seven, and it got their fees wrong too.

Quick test: Compare your customer count, pricing and headline stats across your site, G2, LinkedIn and press releases. Do they match?

Why this is a team problem

Each of the five has a different owner: dev, content, product marketing, PR, ops. That's why "AI visibility" often belongs to no one, and why the upskilling question matters more than the tool question.

Sources: Vercel and MERJ crawler study; Kevin Indig, Growth Memo; Seer Interactive; Profound; Fire&Spark; Ahrefs brand-mention study; Foundation; MIT Sloan Management Review.

You'll be talking with Dee

Where can we help you create more momentum?

Thirty minutes, no pitch deck. Bring the bottleneck, the launch or the question the board keeps asking. Rather start on your own? Your free hub account is waiting.